The Big Read: The Heart is a Lonely Hunter

So let’s talk about the Big Read Book, The Heart is a lonely Hunter, by Carson McCullers. There will be a number of book discussions coming up in the coming weeks and I thought I would get a head start on the discussion questions supplied by the Library’s Big Read Reader’s Guide.

The first question mentions that the title of McCullers’ book is taken from a poem by William Sharp. More clearly stated the title of the poem is "The Lonely Hunter," by William Sharp writing as Fiona MacLeod which can be found in the University of Virginia online library here.

The second part of this question is: “How does this title relate to the novel’s five main Characters? Why might McCullers have changed it from her original title, The Mute?

Many of the essays written about McCuller’s novel speak of five main characters; I believe them all to overlook Singer’s friend Antonapoulos as being the sixth main character, for it is his relationship with Singer, and his absence that is the driving force for all of Singer’s actions. When Singer loses the only friend he has, the only friend with whom he can communicate, albeit ineffectively, he is thrown into the same circumstance as the four characters who share their thoughts with him, being a lonely hunter. But in the eyes of these four characters Singer is something less than they are; where in his relationship with Antonapoulos, Singer is the well spoken visitor that is not fully understood.

An excerpt from Sharp’s poem.
“Deep in the heart of Summer, sweet is life to me still,
But my heart is a lonely hunter that hunts on a lonely hill.
Green is that hill and lonely, set far in a shadowy place;
White is the hunter's quarry, a lost-loved human face:”

Sharp’s poem is melancholy; and reflects on the loss of a loved one. McCullers transposes the poem to frame each characters hunt to rationalize their existence and make a mark in society. The title speaks more to the story of the five main characters than if the author had focused primarily on John Singer, “the mute” and encompasses the theme of isolation more effectively.


We'd love to hear your thoughts on this book! Post a comment, or drop in on one of our upcoming book discussions:

Tuesday, April 13th at 11am: Bordeaux Branch
Tuesaday, April 13th at 7pm: Methodist University
Wednesday, April 14th at 10:30am: North Regional Branch
Wednesday, April 14th at 10:30am: Cliffdale Regional Branch
Monday, April 19th at 7pm: Cool Springs Tavern
Tuesday, April 20th at 12:30pm: Charles W. Chesnutt Library
Tuesday, April 20th at 7pm: Spring Lake Branch
Wednesday, April 21st at 11am: Hope Mills Branch
Thursday, April 22nd at 4pm: John L. Throckmorton Library

Happy reading!

--Larry G.